ETFs vs. index funds: What’s the difference?

Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) and Index Funds both function as bundles that consolidate several types of investments (i.e. stocks and bonds) into a single investment. They are more similar than they are different, but a few considerations can help you decide which is best for you.
By:
Updated: Jul 21, 2022
Listen

Trade your favourite markets with our top-rated broker, Plus500.

4.5/5

CFD service. 82% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

Visit site

ETFs and Index funds are ideal stepping stones into the stock market for a new investor. They are both more stable and less risky investments than, for instance, cherry picking individual stocks. This page shall describe the differences between ETFs and Index Funds to help you learn which best fits your needs and the balance of your portfolio.

What is an ETF?

Copy link to section

An ETF is a bundle of investment securities (i.e. stocks and bonds). Depending on the type of ETF in question, they typically track the performance and yield of a specific index, industry, commodity, or other assets. 

You can sell or buy shares in an ETF on the stock market as you would individual stocks. As a result, ETF prices fluctuate throughout the trading day as they are bought and sold on the market.

What is an index fund?

Copy link to section

An index fund is a subset of a mutual fund or an ETF. Index funds typically provide broader exposure to the market, have a lower rate of portfolio turnover, and often operate on lower expenses. 

Index funds track indexes regardless of the state of the markets. As such, they are typically considered to be ideal stores for retirement accounts (i.e. IRA and 401K).

What’s the difference between ETFs and index funds?

Copy link to section

ETFs and index funds are more similar than they are different. After all, index funds can be a subset of an ETF. To bolster your understanding, we have highlighted some of the key differences between ETFs and index funds below.

  • Methods of buying and selling. How you buy and sell an ETF as opposed to an index fund is the crucial difference between the two. ETFs, like stocks, can be traded throughout the day. Whereas index funds can only be purchased or sold for the set price at the end of the trading day.
  • Initial minimum investment. Typically, ETFs require a smaller minimum investment than index funds because you can buy shares (in some cases, even fractional shares) in ETFs. However, depending on your selected broker for the index fund you are after, there will most likely be a higher minimum initial investment amount required to get your foot through the door. That said, for investors with lower budgets interested in index funds, there are some that do not require any minimum initial investments.
  • Cost of ownership. Different brokers charge different commissions for trading ETFs and index funds. If your broker charges a commission, then you will be liable to pay a flat fee every time you buy or sell shares in an ETF. If your broker charges transaction fees for investing in an index fund, you will be liable to pay these every time you buy or sell. 
  • Capital Gains tax. When you sell a share of your ETF, you are essentially selling it to another investor who is purchasing it, and you pay Capital Gains tax on that sale. Whereas, index funds are less liquid and in order for you to get cash out, the fund manager must sell securities to generate the sale. As this sale will affect every investor in the fund, especially if it is for a gain, you can be liable to pay Capital Gains tax without even selling a share.

Similarities between ETFs and index funds

Copy link to section

Despite their nuanced differences, ETFs and index funds share a lot in common. To expand your knowledge, we have outlined some of the key similarities between ETFs and index funds below. 

  • Affordability. Both ETFs and index funds are comparatively lower cost options for investing in the markets. As both types of investments are usually passively managed, there are typically no management fees when buying or selling shares in either ETFs or index funds. It must be noted however that there are some actively managed ETFs on the market, and you must do your own due diligence when investing on a budget.
  • Expense ratios. Both ETFs and index funds are low cost options as compared to other market alternatives but there are expense ratios associated with both types of investments. Albeit usually minimal, expense ratios are an ongoing cost of ownership for both ETFs and index funds. You should review and evaluate an expense ratio before placing your investment.   
  • Diversification. A combination of even a handful of ETFs and index funds offers you broad and wide-ranging exposure to the market, resulting in a highly diversified portfolio. For instance, an ETF that tracks the performance of the S&P 500 gives you access to some of the world’s largest companies through a single share purchase. 
  • Long-term returns. Long-term investors will be interested to learn that historically, passively managed funds outperform actively managed funds in the long run. As both ETFs and index funds are predominantly passively managed, you stand to gain a better return on your investment in the long term than you would by investing in an actively managed fund.

Which one is right for me?

Copy link to section

If you are an active investor who is interested in intraday trading, then ETFs are the right option for you. You can buy or sell ETF shares (like individual stocks) throughout the trading day. Whereas, you have limited trading ability with index funds as you can only buy or sell shares for a set price at the end of the trading day. 

If you are an investor on a budget, then both ETFs and/or index funds with minimal to zero initial investment deposits are the right options for you. You can buy a single and even fractional shares in most ETFs. There are, however, more limited options for investing in index funds that require a small to none initial investment.

There are key differences and wide similarities between ETFs and index funds. Long-term investors who have allocated a budget and timeframe for their investment do not have to evaluate considerations to the same extent. Both ETFs and index funds are investment bundles that are suitable for investing in the long run. 

The best places to invest

Copy link to section

If you are ready to take the dive and invest in either an ETF or an index fund, the best way to do so requires you to register and set up an account with an online broker. We have selected the top ETF platforms of the market for your ease below.

Sort by:

1
Min. Deposit
$ 100
Best offer
User Score
10
Trade +2000 CFDs on Shares, Options, Commodities & more
Unlimited risk-free Demo Account
0 commissions & attractive spreads with up to 1:5 leverage
Start Trading
Payment Methods:
American Express, Apple Pay, Bank Transfer, Credit Card, Debit Card, Discover, Google Pay, Mastercard, PayPal, SEPA, Trustly, Visa, , skrill
Full Regulations:
ASIC, FCA, FSA, MAS, cysec-250-14-regulator, isa-regulator

CFD service. 82% of retail investor accounts lose money when trading CFDs with this provider. You should consider whether you can afford to take the high risk of losing your money.

2
Min. Deposit
$ 10
Best offer
User Score
9.9
Up to $240 bonus!
Deposit with ACA, Wire, Pay with my bank
Invest for dividends and get payout on stocks on Ex-Dividend day
Start Trading
Payment Methods:
Bank Transfer, Credit Card, Debit Card, PayPal, Wire Transfer
Full Regulations:
CySEC, FCA

Cryptocurrency is offered by eToro USA LLC (“the MSB”) (NMLS: 1769299) and is not FDIC or SIPC insured. Investing involves risk, and content is provided for educational purposes only, does not imply a recommendation, and is not a guarantee of future performance. Invezz.com is not an affiliate and may be compensated if you access certain products or services offered by the MSB.

3
Min. Deposit
$ 0
Best offer
User Score
9.6
Get insights from millions of investors, creators, and analysts
Build your portfolio of stocks, ETFs, and crypto–all in one place
No minimum deposit
Start Trading
Payment Methods:
Bank Wire, Check, Debit Card, Wire Transfer
Full Regulations:
Cryptocurrency execution and custody services are provided by Apex Crypto LLC (NMLS ID 1828849) through a software licensing agreement between Apex Crypto LLC and Public Crypto LLC. Crypto trading on Public platforms is served by Public Crypto LLC and offered through APEX Crypto. Please ensure that you fully understand the risks involved before trading.

A quick recap

Copy link to section

ETFs and index funds are both bundles of securities that provide broad exposure to the market and diversity for your portfolio. Ideal for long-term investors who can wait for the promise of strong returns in the long run, both passively managed investments tend to be low cost alternatives as compared to actively managed funds.

If you are interested in actively trading and allowing for more flexibility in your portfolio, ETFs are the better option for you. Whereas, if you prefer a more passive and low-frills investment strategy, index funds might be the preferred option for you. Whether you opt for an ETF or an index fund will depend on your individual portfolio goals and you must do your own due diligence to best place your investment.



Sources & references
Risk disclaimer
Srijani Chatterjee
Financial Writer
Srijani was a Financial Writer for Invezz covering stocks, investment funds, securities, and commodities. She is UK law-qualified and has worked in both the legal industry... read more.