Robinhood selling users’ shares WITHOUT consent

By: Charlie Hancox
Charlie Hancox
Alongside his passion for trading, Charlie has represented Great Britain and won national championships as a water polo player,… read more.
on Jan 29, 2021
  • Numerous investors report that Robinhood has closed their positions in GameStop (GMC) without consent
  • Latest issues continue a shameful few days for Robinhood, having previously pulled the plug on numerous stocks
  • Allegations that Robinhood has illegally closed positions without the permission of users
  • Investors prepared for a dramatic day of trading as Robinhood vaguely promises ‘limited buys’

Is Robinhood selling users shares without their consent?

Yes, it appears Robinhood have sold stocks in GME worth millions. Reports from outraged users all over the internet are appearing in large numbers. Convenient timing of stocks being sold at the daily low, and an outright refusal to answer the question by CEO Vlad Tenev in numerous interviews makes it a compelling case.

More information below.

‘The 1% don’t want to play the game when everyone else knows the rules.’

Are you looking for fast-news, hot-tips and market analysis? Sign-up for the Invezz newsletter, today.

That is the consensus of the retail investment community, which continues to reel from the impact of Robinhood’s recent actions. Following a gamma squeeze on several stocks including GameStop (GME) and AMC Entertainment Holdings (AMC) – which was initiated by WallStreetBets – Robinhood made a statement that attracted universal condemnation.

Whilst a class action lawsuit has been filed by Robinhood users in relation to market manipulation, the most recent development in this story has definitively crossed the line of legality. 

The empire strikes back

Having limited buying options of numerous stocks on Thursday, the market experienced a dramatic shakedown as investors were unable to open new positions or continue purchasing stock in particular companies. A monumental backlash soon followed, and retail investors pulled no punches. 

When Ted Cruz is agreeing with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on something, it gives you an idea of just how reprehensible the behaviour of Robinhood has been…

If things weren’t already weird enough, we then had to witness the bumbling mess that is Vladimir Tenev struggle through an interview on CNBC. He is the CEO of Robinhood, and his insipid reading of a script did little to placate an investment community that, frankly, has had enough of his bullsh*t. The sole accomplishment of this interview was to further solidify his status as everyone’s clown of the week; scratch that, year.

If there was any doubt before, it is definitely illegal now

So, onto the latest development in this saga, and I never thought I would type these words about a broker. There have been numerous reports of Robinhood selling its users GME shares without permission. Yes, you read that correctly. 

This is totally unprecedented. Never before has a broker liquidated the stocks of its users without permission. 

A screenshot of a recent Robinhood e-mail next to a market information chart. Robinhood is forcibly closing investors' positions.
A screenshot of a recent Robinhood e-mail. Robinhood is forcibly closing investors' positions.

Robinhood has now clearly become Robbinghood, as it illegally betrays the trust of its users by first barricading access to the open market, and then selling their shares without permission to ‘mitigate risk’ for users. It is no surprise to see #boycottrobinhood trending worldwide. 

The message is clear: this is war. This has now gone far beyond any controversy we have seen before, and what is truly alarming is that it has been orchestrated so brazenly and so openly. This is an indication of the ever-shrinking accountability of institutions.

If they behave in such a heinous way when fully in the view of the public, with zero fear of reprimand, think about what they get up to behind your back. This is why decentralised finance has so much momentum right now.

A not-so-hidden motivation

For anyone with a functioning vision, it is obvious that Robinhood is tucked nicely in bed with the hedge funds, but exactly what sort of shenanigans are happening beneath the covers?

Robinhood’s direct involvement with hedge funds that have significant short positions in GME shows the conflict of interest in black and white. 

The primary motivation for Robinhood is its upcoming IPO. In order to secure a strong financing, Robinhood is reliant on the backing of institutional investors. Whilst this might be an effective short-term strategy for Robinhood, it does seem that it has cut off its nose to spite its face. Good luck finding any retail investors to throw their money into the ring come listing day…

Choose a reliable broker

If you want to get involved in today’s drama but have been put off by Robinhood’s actions, sign up to one of our recommended brokers for a more reliable and generally superior experience.

1
Min. Deposit
$10
Promotion
User Score
10
Trade/invest in stocks with just $50
Invest for dividends and get payout on stocks on Ex-Dividend day
Over 11 payment methods, including PayPal
Start Trading
Description:
eToro is a multi-asset investment platform with more than 2000 assets, including FX, stocks, ETF’s, indices and commodities. eToro users can connect with, learn from, and copy or get copied by other users. Buying stocks on eToro is free and you can invest with as little as $50.
Payment Methods
Bank Transfer, Wire Transfer
Full regulations list:
CySEC, FCA
eToro USA LLC does not offer CFDs and makes no representation and assumes no liability as to the accuracy or completeness of the content of this publication, which has been prepared by our partner utilizing publicly available non-entity specific information about eToro. Your capital is at risk.
2
Min. Deposit
$1
Promotion
User Score
9.3
0 Commissions and no deposit minimums
Registered with and regulated by SEC and FINRA
Loss of cash protection
Start Trading
Description:
Financial company driven by technology and offering all-in-one self-directed investment platform that provides excellent user experience.
Payment Methods
Full regulations list:

Years of reputation down the toilet

For Robinhood, a platform with years of hard-earned goodwill from the retail investment community, and even a positive review from us, this move appears to have been an unmitigated disaster. It will be extremely interesting to see how Tenev and his team manage to deflect the pitchfork-wielding mob in the coming days. Be sure to look out for our revised review in the near future.

If there is one positive to take from this situation, remember that WallStreetBets has shown that a bunch of little guys can work together to take down some of the world’s most senior financial institutions, if only for a few days. The degree of permanent change that will occur remains to be seen. 

Make sure you check out our list of the best alternatives to Robinhood; it could become very relevant over the coming hours. We have also listed the brokers to consider if you are based in the United Kingdom and are looking for alternatives to Trading 212.

Invest in crypto, stocks, ETFs & more in minutes with our preferred broker, eToro
10/10
67% of retail CFD accounts lose money